Replied to your FB status, but I thought I'd put somthing here too.
Personally I think New Moon was more true to the book than Eclipse was to it's counterpart. Nonetheless I did love it. Watching Bella attempt to seduce Edward had me laughing because it just looked too hilarious for words. *SIGH* Edward's proposal I was melting I thought Robert Pattinson pulled that scene off really well. I was lloking forward to seeing Alice strong arm Bella into the wedding thing so was disappointed they didn't include that. Also the story of her Porsche!!! I wanted to see Edward give her that car. I agree with your observation that Rosalie was even more b****Y than she normally was.
Another thing that irks me is that she slaps Paul in New Moon causing him to lose his temper and phase and nothing happens to her hand and yet here she slugs Jake and hurts her hand so it didn't make a lot of sense there.
I really was looking forward to this one because Eclipse is my favourite of the series so I am a little disappointed that it wasn't up to where I thought it could be, but I did enjoy the newborn fight and the addition of the newborn army in Seattle backstory.
