Well, I voted yes for both. I think she's just too curious to pass it up. In S1 I see her telling herself that she doesn't care about anything he could possibly write in his diary...but then I think she'd have to prove it. <G> And in S2 I think she'd tell herself it was wrong, but be very torn, and I think eventually she would give in. Maybe *accidentally* knock if off the bookshelf and it just *happened* to fall open. I think that afterwards she'd feel bad about it, but I don't think that would stop her from doing it.
Interesting question!
Annie