folc gave a good first step you clear out the 1 and Weeks from the Newer than date range which will then search every post on the boards. Depending upon how much you know you might want to filter by which forum might have the information you are looking for (Left side upper). The keywords are the next most powerful and there is a link next to "Keyword Search Terms" for "Advanced Search Tips". One of the most important aspects here is the idea of putting a phrase in double quotes like "Dead by the Deadline" BTW the phrase is not case sensitive. Since you believe you have the title click the circular button (actually called radio buttons) next to "in subject" to restrict the search to the subject line of the posts.
Additionally if you just wanted to read the old story you can search the archives at
Lois and Clark Archive . The archive search is quite a bit easier. But this only works if the author submitted the story to the archive after they finished it.
Hope this helps. If you still have issues then reply back with the story name and either myself or someone else should be able to help you find it.
Mike
