As Terry knows, I agree with Tank. My Superman doesn't kill, EVER! It was not his place to be judge, jury and executioner. He had Bill Church in the same condition as he did the other Intergang executives but in this one case he treated him very differently.
Ms. Hunter tried to make us believe that Superman didn't over react because he didn't harm any of the other bad guys but I see that act as proof of guilt rather than extentuating circumstances.
While I feel he should be found guilty I also feel his good deeds could modify his punishment. However, as Clark himself said, a guilty Superman can't be trusted. He killed Bill Church because Superman didn't trust the criminal justice system to punish Church so he did it himself, and that's just wrong.
Ray