|
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 111
Hack from Nowheresville
|
Hack from Nowheresville
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 111 |
Originally posted by skfolc: Whoo boy, do I feel like devil's advocate here or what? I swear I'm not trying to be though! Honest.
Well, I just wanted to add, in respect to situations involving trauma and such, such cases as described are rare, and most importantly after the grieving process has not adequately given the person enough closure - usually persons who engage in such acts also have other instability in their lives, which isn't a case for either Lois or Clark. Dundan - all your points sound valid to me in their own context (at least to my foggy brain at 3 am ), but what you mention above doesn't, in *my* opinion, fit with the story. You say "after the grieving process." In the story, there hasn't *been* any time to grieve "properly." There's only that instantaneous (I'll be amazed if I spelled that right at this hour ) wham of pain and that first stage of denial - this didn't really happen, it couldn't have happened, but somewhere deep down, I know it did, but I don't want to think right now. About anything. And you feel sort of suspended in a place that's not quite reality. That's how I see it. And that's where I think Lois and Clark both were.
And I'm going to stop now. For one, I'm afraid that I really have rambled this time, and for two, Jose's going to see this and know I didn't make it to bed yet. I'm going now, I swear! :p
Sara (who's really starting to wonder about her choice in words - *devil's* advocate - and what that says about the authors ) Sara, you're right  The first paragraph was dealing mainly with a general context not based on the outline of the story, from beginning to its spin. So I suppose we're both right in that regard. lol (Dundan, who kicks Sara back to bed  ) I was mainly referring to Wendy's earlier statement/s.  *You must sleep* 
|
|
Entire Thread
|
FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Bethy
|
11/18/04 12:45 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
KSaraSara
|
11/18/04 01:37 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Vicki
|
11/18/04 02:14 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Tank
|
11/18/04 03:53 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
mariadferdez.
|
11/18/04 04:48 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
SJH
|
11/18/04 05:33 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Quel Lane
|
11/18/04 05:55 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
KathyM
|
11/18/04 06:21 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
ethnica
|
11/18/04 06:34 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Laurach
|
11/18/04 07:28 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
KSaraSara
|
11/18/04 07:52 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
dundan8
|
11/18/04 08:13 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
L
|
11/18/04 08:35 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
ethnica
|
11/18/04 08:59 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Queen of the Capes
|
11/18/04 09:00 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
TicAndToc
|
11/18/04 09:12 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Wendymr
|
11/18/04 09:58 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Trenna
|
11/18/04 10:10 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
daneel
|
11/18/04 11:55 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
dundan8
|
11/19/04 01:42 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
KSaraSara
|
11/19/04 02:19 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
dundan8
|
11/19/04 02:47 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
SJH
|
11/19/04 03:58 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Tank
|
11/19/04 04:09 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
ccmalo
|
11/19/04 04:52 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
YConnell
|
11/19/04 05:59 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Anonymous
|
11/19/04 06:31 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Karla Kent
|
11/19/04 07:23 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
LabRat
|
11/19/04 08:21 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Wendymr
|
11/19/04 08:33 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Mad Dog Lane
|
11/19/04 08:48 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
KathyM
|
11/19/04 10:06 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
dundan8
|
11/19/04 01:11 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
ccmalo
|
11/19/04 02:12 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Artemis
|
11/19/04 06:39 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
TriciaW
|
11/19/04 10:10 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
dundan8
|
11/19/04 11:09 PM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
SJH
|
11/20/04 02:00 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Kaethel
|
11/20/04 02:32 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Julie S
|
11/20/04 09:45 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Wendymr
|
11/20/04 10:06 AM
|
Re: FDK: Whisper from the Dying, 2/?
|
Vicki K
|
12/06/04 12:34 PM
|
|
|